Skip to content
NYNewYorkNewsIN
For you
NeighborhoodBrooklyn Heights

Montero's, the 87-year-old Atlantic Avenue seamen's bar, joins New York's historic business registry

The Brooklyn Heights bar has served sailors, neighbors and karaoke regulars since 1939. Its new owners bought the bar and building for $4.5 million in April and say they won't change it.

Written by NewYorkNews NewsroomNov 20, 2026 · 2 min read · 3 sources
Illustration of the New York harbor waterfront with piers and ships
Key points
  • Montero Bar & Grill at 73 Atlantic Ave. in Brooklyn Heights, open since 1939, has been added to New York's Historic Business Preservation Registry (Brooklyn Paper).
  • The registry honors businesses open 50+ years that shaped their community; it is honorific and brings no state regulation (NYS Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation).
  • The bar first stood at 56 Atlantic Ave. and moved in the early 1940s because of BQE construction; its neon sign dates to 1949 (Brooklyn Paper, citing the registry listing).
  • Brothers Alex and Miles Pincus of Crew Hospitality bought the bar and building for $4.5 million in a sale that closed April 20 (Brooklyn Paper).
  • The new owners say they will keep the bar as it is, and they hope to bring the kitchen back.

For 87 years, the neon sign at Montero Bar & Grill has lit up Atlantic Avenue near the Brooklyn waterfront. Now the state has made the bar's history official. Montero's, at 73 Atlantic Ave. in Brooklyn Heights, has been added to New York's Historic Business Preservation Registry, Brooklyn Paper reported.

What the registry is

The registry, created by state law in 2020, recognizes businesses that have operated for at least 50 years and contributed to their community's history, according to the state Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation, which runs it. A state elected official has to nominate each business. Listed businesses get a certificate, a window decal and promotional help. The listing is honorific only: it does not landmark the building or put the business under any state oversight.

A bar built for sailors

Joseph and Maria Pilar Montero opened the bar in 1939, according to Brooklyn Paper. It started at 56 Atlantic Ave. and moved to No. 73 in the early 1940s when the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway was built. The registry listing, as quoted by Brooklyn Paper, says the new space got a curved entrance and glass blocks, and the neon sign went up in 1949. The listing describes an interior largely unchanged since the bar's official reopening on July 4, 1947: a streamlined glass-block bar with a red countertop, a 1940s National Cash Register, wooden phone booths and hundreds of pieces of seafaring memorabilia.

Advertisement

Before the BQE and Brooklyn Bridge Park, the piers along Atlantic Avenue brought well over 1,000 seamen a day to the strip, the founders' son Joseph "Pepe" Montero told the paper. His father had left Spain to sail on Danish ships, and in the early years the clientele was mostly Danish sailors. Montero, now in his 80s, grew up in the apartment upstairs and later ran the bar with his wife, Linda, until this year. Of the businesses on the strip that once served seamen, Montero's is one of the few still open.

In recent decades the bar has drawn neighbors, sports teams from the leagues in Brooklyn Bridge Park, and a crowd for karaoke nights that host Amethyst Valentino has run for almost two decades, Brooklyn Paper reported.

New owners, same bar

The Monteros sold the bar and the building for $4.5 million to brothers Alex and Miles Pincus, and the sale closed April 20, according to Brooklyn Paper. The brothers run Crew Hospitality, the group behind the nautical-themed Grand Banks and, until recently, Pilot. In Alex Pincus' telling, Montero had already accepted an offer from a developer before the brothers stepped in.

Alex Pincus told Brooklyn Paper there are "no plans to change what it is fundamentally." Since April, the owners have started taking credit cards, made the pool table free and fixed some broken equipment. He hopes to get the kitchen running again to bring in more people on slower nights from Sunday through Wednesday. The bar opens at 4 p.m.

The story first appeared on Brooklyn Paper's sister site, Brownstoner.

Advertisement
Read NYC news in the appFree for iPhone and Android, with the 7 AM briefing as a notification.
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
How this story was madeWritten by NewYorkNews Newsroom from 3 sources · Nov 20, 2026

Every story links to the reporting and records it’s based on. Our editors write each piece from public reporting and official data, and check it against those sources before it’s published.

Advertisement

Comments

0In Community

Your comment is also posted to Community with this story attached, so neighbors can find it and reply there too.

Sign in to join the conversation with your neighbors.

No comments yet

Start the conversation — your comment shows up here and in Community for neighbors nearby.