Morningside Heights neighbors appeal Columbia College Walk ruling and press university at packed town hall to reopen its gates
A state judge ruled last week that the public has no right of access to College Walk. Residents filed an appeal Tuesday, and on Wednesday night students, neighbors and local officials told a Columbia official the locked gates are cutting the campus off from the neighborhood.

Photo: Z3lvs / Wikimedia Commons · CC0
- State Supreme Court Justice David Cohen last week dismissed a neighborhood lawsuit, ruling residents have no right of public access to College Walk (Columbia Spectator).
- Residents filed an appeal on Tuesday, Nov. 17, NY1 and the Spectator reported.
- At a Wednesday town hall, students, former faculty and neighbors pressed a Columbia official to reopen the walkway, which links Broadway and Amsterdam Avenue at 116th Street (ABC7, NY1).
- Columbia says its Campus Access Advisory Committee is studying ways to expand access, with recommendations expected in the coming weeks, ABC7 reported.
- A state Senate bill that would require the gates to stay open is being introduced, according to ABC7; Mayor Mamdani has said the walkway should be public.
The fight over Columbia University's locked gates moved from the courtroom to a packed Morningside Heights town hall Wednesday night, as students, former faculty members, residents and local officials pressed the university to reopen College Walk, the passage that runs through the campus between Broadway and Amsterdam Avenue at 116th Street.
Where the legal fight stands
- The ruling: State Supreme Court Justice David Cohen last week dismissed a lawsuit neighbors filed more than a year ago, finding they "have no right of public access to College Walk," the Columbia Spectator reported. The ruling treats the walkway as university property, ABC7 reported.
- The appeal: residents filed an appeal on Tuesday, Nov. 17, according to NY1 and the Spectator.
- The city: the dismissal came weeks after the Mamdani administration, in a Sept. 29 filing, threatened to sue Columbia if it did not open the gates, the Spectator reported. Mamdani said in October that the city believes College Walk is a public walkway under a decades-old agreement with the university, according to ABC7.
- Albany: a state Senate bill that would require the gates to stay open is being introduced, ABC7 reported.
What neighbors and students said
Columbia first restricted campus access during the 2024 protests over the war in Gaza, and visitors now show ID at a side entrance, NY1 reported. Speakers at the town hall described the closure as turning the campus into a fortress inside the neighborhood and said families who once used the walk as a shortcut to Morningside Park have been shut out. Assemblymember-elect Eli Northrup said the university succeeds when the neighborhood does. Some students told NY1 they would keep badge access for buildings but open the walkway itself.
Columbia's response
A university spokesperson said Columbia "understands the benefits of a more open campus" and pointed to its Campus Access Advisory Committee, whose recommendations are expected in the coming weeks, ABC7 reported. Loftin Flowers, the Columbia representative at the meeting, called the question complex and said he hoped the committee would offer concrete steps soon, according to NY1. CBS New York also covered the town hall.
We'll update this story when the committee reports or the appeal is heard.
- ABC7 New YorkCalls grow to reopen Columbia's gates to public, claiming closure divides community
- NY1Students, neighbors question Columbia over locked campus entrances
- Columbia Daily SpectatorJudge rules Columbia can keep gates closed
- Columbia Daily SpectatorMorningside Heights residents appeal lawsuit to open gates
- CBS New YorkTown hall addresses public access to Columbia University campus
Every story links to the reporting and records it’s based on. Our editors write each piece from public reporting and official data, and check it against those sources before it’s published.



Comments
0NSynced with CommunityIn CommunityYour comment is also posted to Community with this story attached, so neighbors can find it and reply there too.
No comments yet
Start the conversation — your comment shows up here and in Community for neighbors nearby.