NYC's BEST Pizza Places: A Delicious Tour of the 5 Boroughs!
Eater Ny8 months ago
980

NYC's BEST Pizza Places: A Delicious Tour of the 5 Boroughs!

FOOD
pizza
nyc
food
restaurants
eater
Share this content:

Summary:

  • Explore NYC's diverse pizza scene, from coal-fired to Neapolitan styles.

  • Discover iconic pizzerias like Louie & Ernie's, Mama's Too, and John's of Bleecker Street.

  • Try unique slices such as Mama's Too's pear and gorgonzola square and Lucia Pizza's cream of spinach.

  • Experience the legendary deep-fried Montanara pizza at Don Antonio.

  • Indulge in classic NYC slices at Joe's Pizza and Scarr's Pizza.

NYC's Best Pizzerias: A 5-Borough Pizza Pilgrimage

New York City boasts a diverse pizza scene, from coal-fired to Neapolitan, Sicilian, and classic New York-style slices. While the debate rages on about the ultimate best pizza, a few pizzerias have achieved iconic status. This guide highlights must-visit spots across all five boroughs.

Louie & Ernie's Pizza (Bronx)

Louie & Ernie's White Pizza

Open since 1947, this Bronx institution serves thin-crust pies in a cozy setting. Their white pizza and sausage pizza are local favorites. They also offer calzones.

Mama's Too (West Village)

Mama's Too Square Slice

Known for its incredibly delicious and generous square slices, Mama's Too features crunchy crusts and a subtly sweet tomato sauce. Don't miss their poached pear and gorgonzola square!

Rose & Joe's Italian Bakery (Ditmars)

Rose & Joe's Pizza

A unique bakery specializing in pizza, Rose & Joe's offers thick, cheesy square slices with tangy tomato sauce. Arrive when a fresh pie is coming out for the best experience.

Don Antonio (Multiple Locations)

Don Antonio Montanara

Run by Giorgia Caporuscio (2024 Pizza Maker of the Year!), Don Antonio is known for its soft, doughy, slightly charred pizzas, best enjoyed with a knife and fork. Their deep-fried Montanara pizza is a must-try.

John's of Bleecker Street (Greenwich Village)

John's of Bleecker Street

A historic pizzeria dating back to 1929, John's offers thin, coal-oven-fired pizzas sold whole, with various toppings available.

Joe's Pizza (Multiple Locations)

Joe's Pizza Slices

A New York slice champion with multiple locations, Joe's Pizza is a go-to for a classic New York experience.

Arturo's (Greenwich Village)

Arturo's Interior

Since 1957, Arturo's has served coal-oven pizzas in a charming setting with live jazz. They offer a wide variety of toppings and classic Italian-American dishes.

Una Pizza Napoletana (Lower East Side)

Una Pizza Napoletana Margherita

Known for its authentic Neapolitan pizzas, Una Pizza Napoletana uses high-quality ingredients and wood-fired ovens for perfectly charred pies. Open Thursday-Saturday only.

Lucia Pizza (Multiple Locations)

Lucia Pizza Cream of Spinach

Starting as a slice shop, Lucia Pizza now has multiple locations. Their specialty slices, including the cream of spinach and vodka slices, are highly recommended.

Scarr's Pizza (Multiple Locations)

Scarr's Pizza Slice

Owner Scarr Pimentel's perfect slices using freshly ground flour draw lines even at their larger new location.

L'Industrie Pizzeria (Multiple Locations)

L'Industrie Pizza

L'Industrie offers high-quality slices with unique toppings like ricotta, burrata, spicy salami, and truffle oil. Their outdoor seating includes a school bus!

New Park Pizza (Rockaways)

New Park Pizza is known for its excellent slices, a perfect reward after a day at the beach or before a flight from nearby JFK.

L&B Spumoni Gardens (Bensonhurst)

L&B Spumoni Gardens Sign

Since 1939, this Bensonhurst gem offers delicious pillowy square pies and round pizzas. Don't forget to try their spumoni!

Denino's Pizzeria & Tavern (Multiple Locations)

Denino's Clam Pie

Famous for its clam pie, Denino's offers a unique pizza experience, combining minced clams and mozzarella on a crispy crust. Their Greenwich Village location is highly rated.

Comments

0

Join Our Community

Sign up to share your thoughts, engage with others, and become part of our growing community.

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts and start the conversation!

Newsletter

Subscribe our newsletter to receive our daily digested news

Join our newsletter and get the latest updates delivered straight to your inbox.

NewYorkNews.app logo

NewYorkNews.app

Get NewYorkNews.app on your phone!

Other Latest News

NYC Antisemitic Attacker: A Cause for Anti-Israel Activists?

NYC Antisemitic Attacker: A Cause for Anti-Israel Activists?

10 minutes ago
920
NYC Judge Orders ICE to Improve Migrant Detention Conditions

NYC Judge Orders ICE to Improve Migrant Detention Conditions

1 hour ago
950
NYC Fashion Week 2026: Star-Studded Parties & Runway Showdowns!

NYC Fashion Week 2026: Star-Studded Parties & Runway Showdowns!

48 minutes ago
900
Maroon 5 Announces 2 NYC MSG Shows for 'Love is Like' Tour!

Maroon 5 Announces 2 NYC MSG Shows for 'Love is Like' Tour!

3 hours ago
840
Broadway's Victory! Jay-Z's Times Square Casino Bid Rejected

Broadway's Victory! Jay-Z's Times Square Casino Bid Rejected

2 hours ago
940
Times Square Casino Bid Rejected: Broadway vs. Big Bucks!

Times Square Casino Bid Rejected: Broadway vs. Big Bucks!

5 hours ago
920
NYC Fashion Week Spring/Summer 2026: Shadow Selves, Tinsel Gowns, and Star-Studded Front Rows!

NYC Fashion Week Spring/Summer 2026: Shadow Selves, Tinsel Gowns, and Star-Studded Front Rows!

5 hours ago
920
NYC Coffee Crisis: Tariffs Brew Trouble for Local Cafes

NYC Coffee Crisis: Tariffs Brew Trouble for Local Cafes

7 hours ago
860
NYC's New Central Perk: A Permanent 'Friends' Cafe Opens in Times Square!

NYC's New Central Perk: A Permanent 'Friends' Cafe Opens in Times Square!

8 hours ago
840
NYC Mayoral Candidate's Wealth Tax Plan Sparks Debate –  A Transatlantic Political Showdown?

NYC Mayoral Candidate's Wealth Tax Plan Sparks Debate – A Transatlantic Political Showdown?

6 hours ago
890
NYC Mayor Adams Defends Legacy Amidst Heated Mayoral Race

NYC Mayor Adams Defends Legacy Amidst Heated Mayoral Race

20 hours ago
900
NYFW's Final Day: Stunning Designs from PatBo, Kallmeyer & More!

NYFW's Final Day: Stunning Designs from PatBo, Kallmeyer & More!

21 hours ago
930
NYC Strip Club Scandal: Executives Indicted for $8M Tax Evasion Scheme

NYC Strip Club Scandal: Executives Indicted for $8M Tax Evasion Scheme

23 hours ago
810
NYC Weather Alert: Heavy Rain and Gusty Winds Expected Wednesday!

NYC Weather Alert: Heavy Rain and Gusty Winds Expected Wednesday!

23 hours ago
820
Central Perk is Coming to NYC! Iconic 'Friends' Coffee Shop Opens This Fall

Central Perk is Coming to NYC! Iconic 'Friends' Coffee Shop Opens This Fall

22 hours ago
840
OMG! Central Perk is OPENING in NYC!

OMG! Central Perk is OPENING in NYC!

1 day ago
980
Political Violence in America: From Utah to New York, A Wave of Attacks Shakes the Nation

Political Violence in America: From Utah to New York, A Wave of Attacks Shakes the Nation

1 day ago
830
Ryan Reynolds' Generous Act: Helping a Young Cancer Patient's NYC Dream Come True

Ryan Reynolds' Generous Act: Helping a Young Cancer Patient's NYC Dream Come True

1 day ago
890
Hochul Soars, Stefanik Stumbles:  NY Governor's Race Takes a Dramatic Turn

Hochul Soars, Stefanik Stumbles: NY Governor's Race Takes a Dramatic Turn

1 day ago
850
NYC's Trinketcore Trend: Tiny Treasures Taking Over the City!

NYC's Trinketcore Trend: Tiny Treasures Taking Over the City!

1 day ago
850
NYC Judge Drops Terrorism Charges Against UnitedHealthcare CEO's Killer

NYC Judge Drops Terrorism Charges Against UnitedHealthcare CEO's Killer

1 day ago
950
NYC CEO Murder: Terrorism Charges Dropped, But Justice Still Sought!

NYC CEO Murder: Terrorism Charges Dropped, But Justice Still Sought!

1 day ago
830
NYC Foodie Alert! Mexico City's Legendary Pujol Restaurant is Coming for a Limited Time!

NYC Foodie Alert! Mexico City's Legendary Pujol Restaurant is Coming for a Limited Time!

1 day ago
850
NYC's Trash Revolution Conquers Brooklyn:  Empire Bins Take on Rat Infestation!

NYC's Trash Revolution Conquers Brooklyn: Empire Bins Take on Rat Infestation!

1 day ago
870
NYC's Fall Theater Scene: 15 Must-See Shows You Won't Want to Miss!

NYC's Fall Theater Scene: 15 Must-See Shows You Won't Want to Miss!

1 day ago
900
NYC CEO Murder: Terrorism Charges Dropped, But Will Killer Face the Death Penalty?

NYC CEO Murder: Terrorism Charges Dropped, But Will Killer Face the Death Penalty?

1 day ago
840
NYC CEO Murder Trial: Terrorism Charges Dropped, But Will Justice Prevail?

NYC CEO Murder Trial: Terrorism Charges Dropped, But Will Justice Prevail?

1 day ago
930
NYC Judge Dismisses Terrorism Charges Against CEO Killer, Murder Count Remains

NYC Judge Dismisses Terrorism Charges Against CEO Killer, Murder Count Remains

1 day ago
890
NYC Murder Trial: Terrorism Charges Dropped, but CEO's Killer Still Faces Justice

NYC Murder Trial: Terrorism Charges Dropped, but CEO's Killer Still Faces Justice

1 day ago
900
OMG! Central Perk is FINALLY Coming to NYC!

OMG! Central Perk is FINALLY Coming to NYC!

22 hours ago
840