NYC Restaurant Inspections Are Way Behind: What's Happening?

NYC Restaurant Inspections Are Slower Than Ever Due to Staffing Shortages

New York City's beloved restaurants are facing a major issue: a shortage of Department of Health inspectors. This is leading to huge delays in initial inspections and reinspections, leaving some restaurants in limbo for months.

For example, the iconic steakhouse Gallaghers has been waiting for a reinspection for over a year, despite having displayed a misleading "A" grade in its window.

The Mayor's Management Report (MMR) shows that the DOH inspected only 66.4% of restaurants in Fiscal 2024, a significant drop from 83.4% in 2023. This is largely due to staff shortages, the report states.

The Impact on Restaurants

The delayed inspections can have a big impact on restaurants:

• Hanging in Limbo: If a restaurant doesn't get an "A" on its initial inspection, it must keep its lower grade (or "Grade Pending") sign in the window, potentially deterring customers.
• Expensive Appeals: Restaurants have to pay a hefty fee to appeal a lower grade, creating a conflict of interest and raising concerns about the system's objectivity.
• Stressful Waiting: Even if the delays don't affect a restaurant's ability to open, the waiting can be stressful and add to the pressure of everyday operations.

What's the DOH Saying?

The DOH acknowledges the staffing shortage and says they are actively recruiting and training new inspectors. They also claim that the inspection process is still focused on food safety and that most restaurants are safe.

The Bigger Picture

Restaurant owners are feeling the strain of the delays, especially as they grapple with rising labor and food costs and the lingering effects of the COVID-19 pandemic. While the DOH insists on the safety of NYC restaurants, the slow pace of inspections raises concerns about the effectiveness of the city's food safety system.

As restaurants and diners wait for inspections, one thing is clear: the wait is highlighting the challenges the city faces in balancing food safety with the needs of its vibrant restaurant industry.