The Failing-Mayors Trifecta: Adams, Johnson, and Bass

Mayors Eric Adams (NYC), Brandon Johnson (Chicago), and Karen Bass (Los Angeles) are facing widespread disapproval despite being relatively new in office. This article explores the reasons behind their plummeting popularity and the potential consequences.

Chicago's Brandon Johnson: A Progressive Agenda Backfires

Johnson, elected in April 2023, campaigned on a progressive platform focusing on social programs and police reform. He faced criticism for his handling of crime, including shutting down the gunshot detection system and his allocation of $51 million to migrant services. His low approval rating (14% in November 2024) has prompted calls for his recall.

New York City's Eric Adams: From Crime Fighter to Indicted Mayor?

Adams, a former NYPD captain, won the 2021 mayoral race by focusing on crime reduction. While homicides declined under his leadership, other crimes rose, and his handling of the migrant crisis drew heavy criticism. His recent indictment on federal bribery charges has further damaged his standing, with only 8% of Democrats supporting him in a recent poll.

Los Angeles' Karen Bass: Homelessness Crisis and Budget Woes

Bass, elected in 2022, prioritized addressing homelessness. However, her approval ratings have dropped due to the worsening homelessness crisis and her handling of the city's budget. Significant budget cuts, including those impacting the fire department, have led to criticism, particularly after the wildfires. She now faces a recall effort.

The Bigger Picture: A Shift in Political Dynamics?

The failures of these three mayors highlight a broader trend in large American cities where progressive policies are failing to deliver the promised improvements. The article raises the question of whether voters are learning from these failures and whether a shift in political ideology is necessary to improve these major metropolitan areas.