Long Island’s Fighting Tomcats Aim for Giant-Killing Glory in Historic U.S. Open Cup Clash

Everyone loves a good underdog story, and on Sunday night, American Soccer Club New York (ASC) has the chance to write its own chapter in American soccer history.

Based on Long Island, ASC—known as the Fighting Tomcats—is set to face NPSL rival Osner’s FC in a qualifying first-round match for the prestigious U.S. Open Cup. The high-stakes game kicks off at 8 p.m. Sunday at Floyd Bennett Field in Brooklyn.

A Legacy of Underdogs

The U.S. Open Cup is the nation's oldest ongoing national soccer competition, marking its 112th year this season. Often compared to England’s FA Cup, it offers teams from lower divisions a rare opportunity to compete against the highest levels of professional soccer for national glory.

"It's the ultimate heritage of American soccer," said Jim Kilmeade, ASC managing partner and general manager. "Before we had what we had today, we had the U.S. Open Cup... When we launched this club in 2025, we knew this is a club that is always going to play, if accepted, into the U.S. Open Cup, be part of American history."

Kilmeade emphasized the unique opportunity for lower-division clubs: "As a lower-division club, this is your chance. This is your chance to try and rise up and be a giant killer one day."

The Path to Professionalism

As an independent professional organization operating at the fourth tier of the American soccer pyramid, ASC blends amateur eligibility with professional ambitions. While players are not signed to traditional U.S. professional contracts, they earn wages through independent work and community engagement.

The club boasts a strong local following, having hosted crowds of over 1,000 fans at venues like Stony Brook University and Mitchel Athletic Complex. They are currently working to finalize a permanent home base in Suffolk County.

Key aspects of ASC’s mission include:

• Player Development: The club aims to identify, develop, and launch players into the European professional soccer ecosystem.
• Youth Academy: The upcoming ASC Bolla Market Youth Academy will be the first fully-funded youth academy on Long Island, launching this fall.
• Proven Talent: Players like Dylan Lopez (Stony Brook freshman) and Aidan Kolbe (seeking a contract in Germany) exemplify the club's success in nurturing talent.

High Stakes, High History

This marks ASC’s second appearance in U.S. Open Cup qualifying. Out of a record 155 clubs entering the qualifying rounds, only 16 will advance to the main tournament, which features all 27 Major League Soccer teams—including New York City FC and the New York Red Bulls—starting in the round of 64.

Coach John Fitzgerald, who also coaches at Molloy University, expressed excitement about the historic nature of the competition. "The biggest carrot is that if we do continue to win games at our level... maybe at some point, would be really exciting" to play against the big boys.

Despite challenges, such as losing active college players for Sunday’s match, the team relies on experienced original players and new recruits. With leadership from captain Sean Fitzgerald and vice-captain Leo Pinto, the Fighting Tomcats hope to avoid being "the giant that's killed" and instead make groundbreaking strides for Long Island soccer.