Skip to content
NYNewYorkNewsIN
For you
Food & Dining

Staten Island's 115-year-old Superior Chocolates closes its South Avenue factory store but plans a comeback

The Katsoris family's chocolate maker has shut its Bloomfield store and factory, surprising holiday shoppers. The owner says the brand is moving, not closing, and hopes to make chocolate turkeys again by Thanksgiving, or by Christmas.

Written by NewYorkNews NewsroomNov 22, 2026 · 2 min read · 3 sources
An office building at 1130 South Avenue with a red LOVE sculpture out front in Staten Island's corporate park
1130 South Avenue in Bloomfield, Staten Island, on the same stretch as the former Superior Chocolates store at No. 1150 (file photo, 2025).

Photo: Tdorante10 / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0

Key points
  • Superior Chocolates has closed its longtime store and factory at 1150 South Ave. in Bloomfield, Staten Island, SILive reported; its website lists the store as closed every day.
  • Owner Mike Katsoris told SILive the business is 'in transition' and is working toward a new location, with at least limited production hoped for the holidays.
  • Thanksgiving is the target for its chocolate turkeys, but Katsoris said he can't promise it; Christmas is more likely.
  • The roughly 90,000-square-foot plant has been leased to a food-processing and frozen-food distribution company.
  • The family business dates to 1911, when Emmanuel Katsoris began making candy in Port Richmond; customers should watch its Facebook page for updates.

Holiday shoppers heading to Superior Chocolates in Staten Island this month have been finding the doors locked. The 115-year-old chocolatier has closed its longtime store and factory at 1150 South Ave. in Bloomfield, SILive.com reported Sunday, and the company's website now lists the store as closed seven days a week.

But owner Mike Katsoris says the business isn't going away. He told SILive the company is working toward a new location and hopes to restart at least limited production in time for the holidays. "The main thing here is that the business is not closed, that it's in transition," he said.

Turkeys by Thanksgiving? Maybe

The immediate target is Thanksgiving, when Superior's large chocolate turkeys are a big part of the business, but Katsoris said he can't promise the timing; if Thanksgiving proves too ambitious, Christmas is the more likely goal. The company plans to post updates on when and where its products will be available on its Facebook page. Its website still offers online ordering and lists a pickup option at the ShopRite in New Dorp, though it was not clear Sunday which products were in stock.

Advertisement

The old plant is getting a new life: Katsoris said the roughly 90,000-square-foot space has been leased to a food-processing and frozen-food distribution operation, with much of the warehouse being converted to freezer space.

A century of Staten Island chocolate

The business traces its roots to 1911, when Greek immigrant Emmanuel Katsoris started making candy on a marble slab in a small Port Richmond shop, according to SILive. It later moved to Richmond Town and Stapleton before landing in the corporate park, and under George Kaye Katsoris it grew into a major manufacturer, Supreme Chocolatier, that made chocolate for national names. The Bloomfield complex the family developed in 2001 included a 6,000-square-foot store and a glass corridor where visitors watched the factory at work, and generations of Islanders bought its Easter bunnies, Valentine's hearts and holiday boxes there.

"I really want to see our legacy, our family legacy, continue," Katsoris told SILive.

  • Phone: 718-761-9600, per the company's website.
Advertisement
Read NYC news in the appFree for iPhone and Android, with the 7 AM briefing as a notification.
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
Filed underFood & Dining
How this story was madeWritten by NewYorkNews Newsroom from 3 sources · Nov 22, 2026

Every story links to the reporting and records it’s based on. Our editors write each piece from public reporting and official data, and check it against those sources before it’s published.

Opened this weekNew restaurants and shops across the five boroughs.
Advertisement

Comments

0In Community

Your comment is also posted to Community with this story attached, so neighbors can find it and reply there too.

Sign in to join the conversation with your neighbors.

No comments yet

Start the conversation — your comment shows up here and in Community for neighbors nearby.