All five NYC Charter questions passed: what changes for outdoor dining, bike lanes, permits and the rainy day fund
Voters approved every proposal from Mayor Mamdani's Commission on Government Efficiency, with 62% to 72% yes. Staten Island said no to all five. Here is what each one does and when it starts.
Updated Nov. 4: all five Charter questions passed in unofficial results; added vote shares, Staten Island's no vote and when each change takes effect.

Photo: Oleg Yunakov / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0
- All five Charter amendments passed in unofficial results: Q1 63.4%, Q2 61.8%, Q3 65.7%, Q4 67.7%, Q5 72.5% yes, with 97% of scanners reported.
- Staten Island was the only borough where a majority voted no, on all five questions.
- Question 1 merges sidewalk cafe and roadway dining applications and drops the Council's veto over sidewalk cafes; the change takes effect March 1, 2027.
- Question 3 speeds up street-safety and bike/bus lane approvals and fast-tracks sales of small unused city properties, which preservation groups opposed.
- Question 4 creates a single permitting hub for about 40 permits, targeted for Dec. 1, 2029; Question 5 sets a 12% reserve target for the rainy day fund.
Update, Nov. 4: all five questions passed. With 97% of scanners reported, the city Board of Elections' unofficial results had yes winning on every question: Question 1 (public space and outdoor dining) 63.4%, Question 2 (city contracts) 61.8%, Question 3 (street projects, city property and office leases) 65.7%, Question 4 (building permits) 67.7% and Question 5 (rainy day fund) 72.5%. Staten Island was the only borough where a majority voted no, on all five, The City Reporter reported.
"Tonight, New Yorkers voted for a government that moves as fast as they do," Mayor Zohran Mamdani said in a statement. "Now comes the work of turning these votes into results."
When the changes kick in
- Outdoor dining and public space (Q1): the new process takes effect March 1, 2027 and does not apply to applications already submitted, amNY reported.
- Permitting hub (Q4): the target launch is Dec. 1, 2029, depending on funding, and the deadline can be extended, amNY reported.
- Rainy day fund (Q5): by May 2027, the Office of Management and Budget and the comptroller must publish a plan for deposits when the fund is below its 12% target, The City Reporter reported.
Borough-by-borough results are in how New York City voted. Below is our explainer from before the vote on what each question does.
What the five questions do
The questions come from the Commission on Government Efficiency, or COGE, the charter revision commission Mayor Zohran Mamdani created after disbanding the commission his predecessor, Eric Adams, set up on his last day in office, Gothamist reported. COGE held 10 public hearings across the five boroughs before releasing its final proposals in July, the Mayor's Office said. The official ballot text, in every language the city provides, is on the Board of Elections website.
Question 1: Public space and outdoor dining
Yes combines the sidewalk cafe and roadway dining applications into one process, modernizes public-notice rules and removes mandatory hearings and the City Council's power to disapprove sidewalk cafes, while keeping community and Council input. No keeps the current process.
The city says it now takes up to eight months to get an outdoor dining permit; the commission says the change would cut that to about two months and save a restaurant up to $1,800 in fees. City data show the number of businesses with outdoor dining has fallen about 90% from pandemic highs, Gothamist reported. Restaurants and the Regional Plan Association support the measure.
Question 2: City contracts
Yes lets the Procurement Policy Board simplify the long questionnaire every city contractor fills out, requires the board to meet quarterly, replaces a required public hearing with a written comment period and lets the mayor delegate some contract approvals. No leaves the rules as they are. The city paid outside contractors $42.3 billion last fiscal year, about 40% of its budget, and nonprofits have long complained about late contracts and payments, according to Gothamist.
Question 3: Street projects, city property and office leases
Yes reduces the number of agencies that must sign off on street-safety projects, including bike and bus lanes, fast-tracks the sale or lease of unused city property with City Planning Commission approval, and speeds up leasing offices for city workers. No keeps the current reviews, including Council approval of property dispositions.
The commission estimates bike and bus lanes would be built about 33% faster. Transportation Alternatives backs it. The NYC E-Vehicle Safety Alliance opposes it, saying it cuts community input, and Reinvent Albany objected to bundling unrelated issues into one question, Gothamist reported.
Question 4: Building permits
Yes creates a central digital hub for about 40 construction permits now issued by 18 offices and agencies, moves waterfront permitting from the Department of Small Business Services to the Department of Buildings and lets more DOB officials approve construction. No keeps the current system.
Question 5: The rainy day fund
Yes sets a target of holding reserves equal to 12% of tax revenue, requires the mayor to develop a formula for deposits, reviewed at least every four years and subject to budget approval, and sets rules for large withdrawals in a "compelling fiscal need" such as a recession. No leaves the fund, now about $2 billion, without a target.
The Citizens Budget Commission says the 12% target is too low, closer to 16% would be prudent, and that the language gives the mayor too much room to decide what counts as a fiscal need, Gothamist reported.
- NYC Board of ElectionsUnofficial Election Night Results, Nov. 3, 2026 (all contests)
- The City ReporterMamdani Ballot Proposals on Public Space, Street Safety and More Pass in NYC
- amNYNYC voters approve all five ballot proposals to overhaul city government
- GothamistBallot questions ask NYC voters whether to cut red tape on outdoor dining, bike lanes
- NYC Mayor's OfficeCOGE Releases 5 Ballot Proposals and Final Report to Make Government Work Better for New Yorkers
- NYC Board of ElectionsBallot Proposals
Every story links to the reporting and records it’s based on. Our editors write each piece from public reporting and official data, and check it against those sources before it’s published.



Comments
0NSynced with CommunityIn CommunityYour comment is also posted to Community with this story attached, so neighbors can find it and reply there too.
No comments yet
Start the conversation — your comment shows up here and in Community for neighbors nearby.