Delivery Protection Act: Amazon warns NYC shoppers of up to $5 more per order; Menin calls it 'deceptive'
Amazon pop-ups say Intro 518 could add up to $5 per order. Speaker Julie Menin and sponsor Tiffany Cabán call the claim dishonest, and Menin is open to amending the bill, which has 35 sponsors but sits in committee.
Updated Nov. 19 with Amazon's customer pop-ups warning of up to $5 more per order, responses from Speaker Menin and sponsor Tiffany Cabán, and Thursday's Queens rally by delivery contractors.

Photo: Tdorante10 / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0
- This week Amazon showed customers pop-ups warning Intro 518 could raise costs by up to $5 per order and urging them to call Council members (ABC7, amNewYork).
- Speaker Julie Menin called it a 'deceptive campaign'; sponsor Tiffany Cabán says the bill requires a $500 license every two years and called the $5 claim 'dishonest.'
- Menin is open to dropping the ban on third-party delivery firms and instead licensing and regulating warehouses (ABC7).
- Amazon says 40+ local delivery businesses and 5,000+ jobs are at risk; a Nov. 16 letter for an Amazon-led coalition and the National Urban League threatened to sue.
- The bill has 35 sponsors and remains in the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection.
Update, Nov. 19: Amazon warns customers of up to $5 more per order; Menin calls it 'deceptive'
- The pop-ups: Amazon took its fight to customers this week with banners and pop-up messages in its app and website warning that the bill could raise prices and delivery costs, with one message citing costs of up to $5 per order, ABC7 reported. The messages urge users to contact their Council members. Amazon did not say how it arrived at the figure, amNewYork noted.
- Amazon's case: the company says the bill would bar it from working with its delivery service partners and force it to consider moving operations out of the city, which would "likely mean slower and more expensive delivery." It says more than 40 small delivery businesses and over 5,000 New Yorkers they employ are at stake.
- The pushback: Speaker Julie Menin called it a "deceptive campaign" and said the Council is crafting legislation that regulates Amazon "without impacting prices or jobs." Sponsor Tiffany Cabán said the bill would require a $500 licensing fee every other year and called the $5 claim "simply dishonest." Mayor Zohran Mamdani wrote on social media that if Jeff Bezos adds $5 to an order, "it's greed."
- Possible changes: Menin said she is open to modifying the bill, possibly dropping the ban on third-party delivery companies and instead licensing and regulating warehouse operations, ABC7 reported.
- The rally: delivery contractors, workers and the Queens Chamber of Commerce, part of the New York Delivers Coalition, rallied in Queens on Thursday and hand-delivered meeting requests to Council members, including Cabán. The coalition says nearly 80% of the affected workforce lives outside Manhattan, 36% in Queens.
- Status: Intro 518 now has 35 sponsors and remains in the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection, amNewYork reported.
Nov. 16: Amazon-backed coalition and the National Urban League threaten to sue
- The letter: in a letter sent Monday to Speaker Julie Menin and other Council members, attorney Derek Sells, retained by the National Urban League and a business coalition led by Amazon, wrote that Intro 518 "directly conflicts with existing federal and state law" and urged members not to pass it in its current form, City & State reported. Sells, National Urban League President Marc Morial and the New York Delivers Coalition planned a news conference in Harlem on Monday morning.
- Still in committee: the bill has not moved since an April hearing of the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection. Menin said last month that Mamdani administration lawyers have raised legal concerns, and she is open to amending it, possibly dropping the ban on hiring through third-party delivery companies, according to The New York Times as cited by City & State.
- Menin's position: "I am determined to pass a bill that both protects these workers and keeps these jobs in our city," Menin said in a statement to City & State, adding that Amazon should adhere to a licensing framework.
- The money: the National Urban League's website lists Amazon as a "diamond partner," meaning more than $1 million in donations, City & State noted. Amazon has threatened to close warehouses and move thousands of workers out of the city if the bill passes.
Oct. 22: the City Hall rally
The fight over how Amazon and other companies get packages to New Yorkers' doors moves to the steps of City Hall on Thursday. Supporters of the Delivery Protection Act scheduled a rally for 10:30 a.m., and Mayor Zohran Mamdani is expected to join Teamsters General President Sean O'Brien, Queens Council Member Tiffany Cabán, the bill's sponsor, and other labor leaders, amNewYork reported. Consumer and Worker Protection Commissioner Sam Levine is also expected.
What the bill would do
- Licenses: operators of certain last-mile delivery facilities, the warehouses where packages are sorted for the final leg, would need a license from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection and would have to meet safety, training and employment standards.
- Direct employment: after a phase-in period, operators would generally have to employ the workers doing core warehouse and delivery jobs themselves, rather than relying on third-party contractors. Amazon's vans are largely driven by employees of independent "delivery service partners."
Where it stands
The bill has 34 sponsors, well above the 26 votes needed to pass, but has stayed in committee since an April hearing, according to amNewYork. (City & State counted Cabán and 32 colleagues.) Speaker Julie Menin has not said publicly whether she supports it. Asked whether it would get a vote, a Council spokesperson told amNewYork only that the bill "is going through the Council's legislative process."
Mamdani, who endorsed the bill in August, accused Amazon on Tuesday of spending heavily "to fear-monger" about it, citing ads on streaming services. Asked whether the bill could cost jobs, he said it would lead to "better protections for workers."
The opposition
State lobbying disclosures show Amazon gave $5,001,377 to the Five Boroughs Jobs Campaign between February and May, and the campaign reported more than $5 million in lobbying expenses in the first half of 2026, naming the bill as a target, amNewYork reported. Amazon says the bill would threaten more than 40 local delivery partners and the jobs of more than 5,000 people they employ; an analysis commissioned by the campaign put the number of jobs at risk above 10,000.
The National Urban League has come out against the bill, its president, Marc Morial, telling City & State that it would wipe out Black-owned delivery businesses that contract with Amazon. The group's website lists Amazon among its top-tier donors, City & State noted. Two Bronx delivery contractors also warned the bill could put their operations at risk, amNewYork's sister paper, the Bronx Times, reported.
Supporters point to street safety as well as labor conditions: a September analysis by the advocacy group ALIGN counted 14,210 traffic violations tied to Amazon-related vehicles in the city from July 2021 to June 2025. Amazon says its delivery partners are responsible for following traffic laws and that it works with them on safety.
- City & StateAmazon, National Urban League threaten to sue city if Delivery Protection Act passes
- amNewYorkMamdani accuses Amazon of trying to 'fear-monger' as he gears up for delivery worker bill showdown
- City & State New YorkDebate picks up over Delivery Protection Act
- Action NetworkRally to Pass the Delivery Protection Act!
- amNewYorkNYC Council could add up to $5 per Amazon order, retail giant says, as delivery workers rally against proposed bill
- ABC7 New YorkAmazon warns of higher costs in NYC if new bill passes
Every story links to the reporting and records it’s based on. Our editors write each piece from public reporting and official data, and check it against those sources before it’s published.



Comments
0NSynced with CommunityIn CommunityYour comment is also posted to Community with this story attached, so neighbors can find it and reply there too.
No comments yet
Start the conversation — your comment shows up here and in Community for neighbors nearby.